How to Rate the Best Games According to Expert Reviewers


Most read

Loading Most Ready posts..

The gaming industry is in the midst of a renaissance, with a slew of high-profile releases captivating players around the globe. Game enthusiasts have witnessed a continuous stream of AAA blockbusters and innovative indie gems this year. 

Since it’s the beginning of a new year of games, It’s time to closely examine how expert reviewers evaluate and rate these gaming masterpieces.

In a world flooded with video games, entire game reviews guide players navigating the vast gaming galaxy. Expert game reviews offer a lifeline, helping players make informed choices amidst the sea of titles vying for their attention.

Expert reviewers, armed with years of experience and an in-depth understanding of the medium, provide valuable insights into the strengths and weaknesses of any video game.

These reviews are more than mere opinions; they are a culmination of rigorous analysis, critical evaluation, and a commitment to uncovering the essence of each gaming experience.

These reviewers employ a meticulous evaluation process, examining gameplay mechanics, graphics, storytelling, sound design, and more. They aim to provide readers with a comprehensive understanding of a game’s strengths and weaknesses, enabling players to align their preferences with the right titles.

Analyzing top-rated games

The criteria for rating video games

Expert reviewers employ well-defined criteria when assessing and rating video games. These criteria are the foundation for evaluating a game’s performance.

The goal is to provide an objective assessment that assists players in making informed choices.

The key criteria for rating video games include gameplay mechanics, graphics and visuals, storytelling and narrative, sound and music, replayability and longevity, and innovation and originality.

These elements contribute to the overall gaming experience and can significantly impact a game’s rating.

The importance of expert opinion

Expert opinion in the realm of video game reviews holds substantial weight. It serves as a compass for players, guiding them toward exceptional gaming experiences and helping them avoid disappointments.

Expert reviewers are individuals with extensive experience in the industry, and their assessments are backed by years of gaming knowledge.

Players often rely on expert opinions to gauge a game’s quality and whether it aligns with their preferences. These opinions transcend personal biases and are grounded in a broader understanding of the video game history, trends, mechanics, and game design principles.

Notable video game releases in 2023

2023 has witnessed an impressive array of video game releases that have left their mark on gaming history. The year has been a treasure trove for gamers, from great first games released, to highly anticipated sequels to great third games released, to groundbreaking new IPs.

Some other games notable releases include “Alan Wake 2,” a masterpiece of scares and storytelling by Remedy Entertainment, and “Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty,” marking the game’s redemption with captivating storytelling.

“The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom” has taken players on a revelatory adventure, while the “Resident Evil 4” remake sets a new standard for classic game remakes.

How to rate video games?

When rating a video game, expert reviewers follow a systematic approach encompassing a range of factors.

These factors collectively determine the overall quality of a video game, and provide players with valuable insights into what to expect. Here are the key considerations:

Gameplay mechanics

Gameplay is the heart of any video game. Reviewers closely examine the mechanics that govern player interactions within the game world. They assess the controls, responsiveness, and overall gameplay experience. The depth and innovation of gameplay mechanics can significantly impact a game’s rating.

Graphics and visuals

Visual fidelity is crucial in immersing players in a game’s world. Reviewers evaluate the quality of graphics, art direction, and technical performance. High-resolution textures, realistic animations, and artistry contribute to a game’s visual appeal and can influence its rating.

Storytelling and narrative

A compelling narrative can elevate a game to new heights. Reviewers assess the depth of storytelling, character development, and the impact of player choices on the game design narrative. A well-crafted story can draw players into the game’s world and leave a lasting impression.

Sound and music

Sound design and music contribute to a game’s atmosphere and emotional impact. Expert reviewers evaluate the quality of voice acting, sound effects, and the soundtrack. A well-composed score and immersive audio can enhance the overall gaming experience.

Replay-ability and longevity

Games that offer replay value and extended gameplay have an advantage. Reviewers consider whether a game provides additional content, side quests, or multiplayer modes that extend its longevity. A game or multiplayer mode’s ability to keep players engaged over time can affect its rating.

Innovation and originality

Originality and innovation set games apart. Reviewers assess whether a game is original and introduces fresh ideas, mechanics, or concepts that push the boundaries of the medium. Games that break new ground and offer unique game experiences often receive higher ratings.

The best games in different genres

The gaming industry in 2023 has truly showcased an impressive diversity of genres, each offering unique experiences and many games that cater to a wide range of player preferences.

From classic RPGs to intense survival horror, action-packed adventures, competitive racing and sports titles, thought-provoking puzzle and strategy games, and even standout indie gems, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Expert reviewers have identified the best games in these genres, catering to various player preferences.

RPG excellence

Role-playing games (RPGs) have consistently been a cornerstone of the gaming world, and in 2024, they continue to shine brightly. 

Games like “Final Fantasy 16”, “Persona 4 Golden”, “Star Wars”, “Dragon Age”, “Team Fortress”, “Dark Souls”, and “Final Fantasy VI” have upheld the tradition of RPG excellence. These titles are known for their immersive storytelling, deep character development, and epic adventures that captivate players for hours. 

In “Final Fantasy 16,” players are transported to a beautifully crafted fantasy world filled with political intrigue and magical battles. At the same time, “Persona 4 Golden” dives into a small town’s intricate relationships and supernatural mysteries. 

These RPG best games offer rich experiences that leave a lasting impact on players and exemplify the high standards set by the genre.

Survival horror standouts

Survival horror, a genre known for keeping players on the edge of their seats, has seen a resurgence in 2023 with titles like “Dead Space” and “Resident Evil 4 Remake.”

Dead Space

This masterfully crafted game plunges players into the eerie, claustrophobic confines of a derelict spaceship. As they navigate its sinister corridors, they’ll confront grotesque alien creatures and unravel a haunting narrative that keeps them at the edge of their seats. “Dead Space” exemplifies the essence of survival horror, rekindling the genre’s terrifying allure.

Resident Evil 4 Remake

“Resident Evil 4 Remake” revisits the iconic Resident Evil series, breathing new life into a classic that defined survival horror gaming. The game offers enhanced graphics and gameplay, while preserving the heart-pounding tension and fear-inducing moments that made the original a timeless favorite.

As players dive into this revamped nightmare, they’ll rediscover the essence of survival horror, reminding them why they were drawn to the genre in the first place. This remake sets a new standard for horror gaming, ensuring that fear remains an enduring element in the gaming world.

Action-packed adventures

For gamers seeking heart-pounding action and adrenaline-fueled adventures, titles like “Bayonetta Origins: Cereza and the Lost Demon”, “Super Smash Bros”, and “Grand Theft Auto III” are must-play experiences.

Bayonetta Origins

“Bayonetta Origins” delivers fast-paced combat, memorable characters, and a captivating storyline that immerses players in a world of witches, angels, and demons. 

Super Smash Bros

Meanwhile, “Super Smash Bros” remains a fan favorite on the Nintendo Switch. The game brings together an extensive roster of characters from various franchises for frenetic battles that can be enjoyed solo, in multiplayer mode, or with friends.

Grand Theft Auto III

Grand Theft Auto III is hailed as one of the greatest video games in the adventure genre. Its immersive storytelling, vast urban landscape, and freedom to explore make it a timeless classic. It’s one of the best console games. 

Some of the other beloved games in the action-packed adventure genre include Metal Gear Solid, Modern Warfare, Mortal Kombat, Metroid Prime, Super Mario Galaxy, Super Mario Odyssey, and Monkey Island.

These games offer pure, unadulterated excitement. They have a mass effect and they are a must play for any action-packed gamer.

Racing and Sports titles

In racing and sports titles, “Forza Motorsport” and “Super Mario Kart” dominate their respective categories.

Forza Motorsport

“Forza Motorsport” offers precision racing, stunning visuals, and a vast array of meticulously detailed cars and tracks, making it a go-to choice for racing enthusiasts who crave authenticity and realism. 

Super Mario Kart

On the other hand, “Super Mario Kart” remains the pinnacle of fun and competitive racing, with its colorful characters, creative power-ups, and engaging multiplayer modes ensuring hours of lighthearted enjoyment for players of all ages. The game is available on Nintendo Switch.

These two games also demonstrate the enduring appeal of the racing and sports genres, offering distinct experiences that cater to different tastes within these categories.

Puzzle and strategy games

Puzzle and strategy games have also flourished in 2023. “Cocoon” and “Sea of Stars” are other games that offer intricate puzzles and innovative gameplay mechanics that challenge players’ minds while providing rewarding experiences.

Indie Gems

Indie games have a significant impact, with titles like “Hi-Fi Rush” and “Shadow Gambit: The Cursed Crew” proving that smaller studios can deliver exceptional experiences. These indie gems provide unique gameplay and creative storytelling that rival larger productions.

Platform Games

Platformer games is a popular video game genre known for its precise jumping and obstacle navigation. “Super Meat Boy,” developed by Team Meat, stands out with its challenging gameplay, quirky humor, and unique art style.

In the Super Meat Boy game, players control Meat Boy in a quest to rescue Bandage Girl. The gamers face treacherous levels and humorous characters, making it a memorable addition to the platform gaming genre.

Balancing critic and player reviews

Expert vs. user reviews

Evaluating any game involves a delicate balance between expert and user reviews. Expert reviewers provide in-depth analysis, while user reviews reflect the sentiments of the online gaming community. Both perspectives are valuable and provide different insights.

Pros and cons of expert opinions

Expert reviews are critical for assessing gameplay mechanics, graphics, narrative, and more. However, they are not infallible and can sometimes miss the mark in reflecting the preferences of the broader player base.

The voice of the gaming community

User reviews, on the other hand, represent the voice of the gaming community. They offer diverse perspectives and personal experiences, but emotions and biases can also influence them.

The importance of regular updates

Review reassessment

Game updates and their impact

Regular updates have become a cornerstone of modern gaming, enhancing player experiences and extending the lifespan of games. These updates often bring improvements, new content, and bug fixes, significantly impacting a game’s overall quality.

Review reassessment

In response to significant updates, expert reviewers may revisit their initial assessments of a game to provide players with an updated perspective. This practice ensures that reviews reflect the current state of a game.

Games as a Service Model

Analyzing user reviews

Games adopting a “games as a service” model evolve with continuous content drops. Analyzing user reviews can offer valuable insights into how players perceive these ongoing experiences.

User-generated content and ratings

Player-created content and user-generated ratings contribute to the evolving nature of games as a service. These elements often play a crucial role in shaping a game’s long-term success.

The value of player feedback

Developers increasingly rely on player feedback to fine-tune their games. Player input can influence updates, balancing changes, and game direction.

Looking beyond review scores

The influence of award shows

Award shows like The Game Awards celebrate excellence in gaming. Recognizing outstanding games and developers serves as an acknowledgment of the industry’s achievements.

Awards and recognition encourage developers to strive for excellence and innovation in game design. The spotlight is reserved for a few games that are exceptional and deserve recognition.

The future of game reviews

Game criticism is an evolving field, adapting to new industry trends and technologies. As gaming continues to evolve, so is how games are reviewed and assessed.

Emerging trends in game reviewing include a focus on accessibility, diversity, and the impact of virtual reality and augmented reality on the gaming experience. Game reviewers adapt to these changes to provide relevant insights to players.


2023 has been a remarkable year for the gaming industry, with an impressive release lineup that has captivated players worldwide. The year has showcased the diversity and creativity inherent in gaming, from fighting games to groundbreaking sequels and innovative new IPs.

Expert reviewers play an indispensable role in this ever-expanding gaming universe. Their objective analysis, in-depth reviews, and commitment to honesty provide players with the guidance they need to navigate this dynamic world.

Since it’s the beginning of 2024, the gaming community eagerly anticipates the future. One thing remains certain—expert reviewers will continue to be trusted guides, ensuring players make informed choices and celebrate the excellence that defines the gaming industry.


What is the role of expert reviewers in the gaming industry?

Expert reviewers provide critical assessments of video games to help players make informed decisions.

How do expert reviewers evaluate games?

They assess gameplay mechanics, graphics, narrative, and overall player experience.

What are some of the popular gaming genres?

Some of the best gaming genres include RPGs, Racing, Horror, Puzzles and Arcade games.

How do updates affect game reviews?

Significant updates may lead to reassessment by expert reviewers to reflect a game's current state.

Why are awards shows important in gaming?

Awards celebrate excellence, inspire innovation, and recognize outstanding games and developers.

Disclaimer: The information provided is not trading advice. Cryptopolitan.com holds no liability for any investments made based on the information provided on this page. We strongly recommend independent research and/or consultation with a qualified professional before making any investment decision.

Share link:

Benson Mawira

Benson is a blockchain reporter who has delved into industry news, on-chain analysis, non-fungible tokens (NFTs), Artificial Intelligence (AI), etc.His area of expertise is the cryptocurrency markets, fundamental and technical analysis.With his insightful coverage of everything in Financial Technologies, Benson has garnered a global readership.

Stay on top of crypto news, get daily updates in your inbox

Related News

Subscribe to CryptoPolitan