🔥Early Access List: Land A High Paying Web3 Job In 90 Days LEARN MORE

Sky ecosystem proposes to vote on off-boarding risky WBTC

In this post:

  • Lending vaults from Sky Lend and legacy loans will be de-risked, with the potential to switch to new cbBTC-wrapped tokens from Coinbase. 
  • WBTC is widely spread to multiple L1 and L2 chains and may not be easy to unwind entirely. 
  • The wrapped token continues to publish proof of reserves, though creating doubts about who controls the underlying BTC.

Sky, formerly known as MakerDAO, announced a vote to divest WBTC from all its loan and collateral facilities. Removing WBTC was discussed earlier as a form of risk mitigation due to uncertainties with the asset’s multi-sig wallets. 

Spark Lend and Sky, formerly MakerDAO, will remove WBTC from its asset mix after a community vote. The call to remove WBTC from the mix comes after the asset’s custodian, BitGo, decided to redistribute three of the multi-sig wallets to third-party institutions. The handover of some of the multi-sig keys is expected on October 8, and Sky will try to de-risk collaterals by that point. 

WBTC has been a significant source of yearly earnings from vaults, but is now considered at risk of contagion or loss of reputation for Sky and Spark Lend. 

In the initial stage, users will be able to unwind their loan positions. But Sky is dedicated to erasing all WBTC from its debts, so a second stage has been proposed, where the conditions for liquidations will become more strict, force-liquidating all outstanding loans. In the worst-case scenario, Sky will liquidate all outstanding loans in the span of three weeks. 

The voting proposal coincided with the live launch of Coinbase BTC (cbBTC) on September 12. The asset will be available to replace the positions on Sky Lend. There have always been attempts to create new forms of wrapped tokens, though most are considered riskier and are less active. Wrapping BTC is a compromise decision, which creates significant counterparty risk.

See also  Diddy hires Sam Bankman-Fried’s attorney for legal representation

The worries come from BitGo’s decision to partner with Tron’s founder, Justin Sun. BitGo has claimed Sun has no way of moving or controlling the underlying BTC reserves. However, Sky still decided to move to Coinbase-wrapped BTC (cbBTC). Justin Sun has denied any control over private keys or the ability to move the underlying BTC, stating his participation in the project is strictly strategic.

For MakerDAO, WBTC collateral supports $200M in DAI loans. Even before offloading, the lending protocol did not consider WBTC a Native Vault Engine asset and has called for unwinding whenever appropriate. 

The debt collateralized with WBTC is split between $73M on Sky Lend and $127M in legacy vaults from MakerDAO. The legacy debt has decreased from $155 million in late August, shortly after the first concerns about WBTC emerged.

The crypto community has also started a wider petition to stop the shift of WBTC to BitGlobal custody with added counterparty risks. 

WBTC is still the leading asset on Ethereum

Even with divestment from MakerDAO, WBTC is one of the most influential wrapped form of BTC. More than 96.6% of BTC on the Ethereum chain is in the form of WBTC, spread across multiple protocols. 

Sky ecosystem proposes vote on off-boarding risky WBTC
Source: Dune Analytics

WBTC has become more distributed and decentralized over the past year after initially having most of its supply on Ethereum. Lately, WBTC has also flowed into Solana for bridging and is highly active on Optimism and Arbitrum. WBTC is spreading aggressively to smaller chains as well as influential platforms like Base. Tokenized BTC is also available for DEX swaps, forming some of the most liquid pairs. Paradoxically, the high number of users on L2 chains and Solana does not account for the largest value transfers of WBTC. Ethereum still serves as a settlement layer, with Arbitrum in the second place. 

See also  Bitcoin just had its best September in history

So far, WBTC has not spread into the TRON ecosystem, which has previously sparked skepticism on the availability of organic users and volumes. Previously, Tron has shown problems with its USDD stablecoin, which de-pegged on several occasions. Using WBTC on Tron is creating new suspicions of contagion, as well as non-organic activity.

The other concern for WBTC is that its supply has been fragmented and moves with little warning to all counterparties. Known addresses of BitGo and wrapped BTC vaults hold a total of 153,205 BTC with a custodian. The coins have been held with a US-based custodian, and the shift to BitGlobal with a new set of multi-sig keys is creating worries in the community. 

Currently, the WBTC project provides transparent proof of assets and has not caused contagion or issues for the wider ecosystem. Even now, WBTC is controlled by a single entity, with its reserves spread across different addresses. To complicate matters, WBTC also exists in bridged and native form on some chains, making it even more difficult to unwind. 


Cryptopolitan reporting by Hristina Vasileva

Share link:

Disclaimer. The information provided is not trading advice. Cryptopolitan.com holds no liability for any investments made based on the information provided on this page. We strongly recommend independent research and/or consultation with a qualified professional before making any investment decisions.

Most read

Loading Most Read articles...

Stay on top of crypto news, get daily updates in your inbox

Related News

Cryptopolitan
Subscribe to CryptoPolitan

Interested in launching your Web3 career and landing a high-paying job in 90 days?

Leading industry experts show you how with this brand new course: Crypto Career Launchpad

Join the early access list below and be the first to know when the course opens its doors. You’ll also save $100’s off the regular launch price.