President Donald Trump’s proposal to eliminate capital gains taxes on crypto has unleashed a storm of debates in Washington, Wall Street, and Silicon Valley. Mostly, because it would be a fiscal Pandora’s box.
According to Trump’s plan, cryptocurrencies issued by US-based entities would no longer face capital gains taxes. The administration argues this would drive innovation, attract international companies, and create a freer crypto economy.
On the other side of the conversation, skeptics, including economists and financial analysts, see a host of problems brewing beneath the surface.
Fairness concerns
At its core, the plan disrupts the principle of uniform taxation. Right now, capital gains taxes apply equally to all investments—stocks, real estate, bonds, and crypto. Trump’s exemption for crypto breaks this standard, creating what some call a tax carve-out for a single sector.
“If a lower capital gains tax rate is the goal, it should apply to all assets,” one Bloomberg economist said. Singling out crypto opens the door for other industries to demand their exemptions. Energy companies, tech startups, or even real estate developers could argue their sectors are just as deserving.
The result? A fragmented tax system full of loopholes benefiting those with the most lobbying power. The US tax code is already complex, and it is loaded with exceptions that cater to specific industries.
Adding crypto to the mix would deepen the disaster. Critics fear this selective favoritism could lead to an economic snowball effect, with more industries vying for similar treatment.
Crypto as a political tool
The optics of Trump’s plan also bring questions about whether crypto’s booming political influence is shaping policy. Major crypto firms and their executives were among the top donors to Trump’s campaign. While there’s no concrete evidence of quid pro quo, the timing of this proposal is hard to ignore.
Critics warn that policies like this set dangerous precedents. Future administrations could use tax exemptions as rewards for political donations, turning economic policy into a tool for fundraising. This not only erodes public trust but also fuels the perception that tax breaks are for sale to the highest bidders.
For the crypto industry, such favoritism might do more harm than good. It risks associating the sector with backroom deals and political lobbying, undermining its push for legitimacy. A tax exemption that smells like political payback could alienate allies and embolden critics.
Volatility and the risks to investors
Trump’s plan could change the profile of crypto investors in the US—and not in a good way. By exempting crypto from capital gains taxes, the policy might attract lower-income investors seeking tax-free savings. While that sounds like a win for accessibility, it puts financially vulnerable individuals at risk.
Crypto remains a volatile market, infamous for wild price swings and speculative bubbles. Encouraging underprepared investors to see crypto as a “safe” tax-free haven could lead to devastating losses. Scams, hacks, and fraud are still rampant in the industry. Lower-income investors are less likely to have the resources—legal or financial—to navigate these risks.
Meanwhile, wealthier investors and institutions with financial expertise would benefit disproportionately. They have the lawyers, accountants, and advisors to exploit new tax loopholes while managing risk. A tax exemption might widen the gap between those who understand crypto and those who don’t, leaving the most vulnerable holding the bag when the market crashes.
Tax arbitrage: The loophole gold rush
A tax-free crypto policy could also lead to creative ways of avoiding taxes altogether. Imagine a world where traditional investments are repackaged as crypto tokens to escape taxation. Why hold shares in a company when you can own a crypto token tied to the same equity?
This kind of tax arbitrage is already possible but difficult under current regulations. Trump’s proposal could make it mainstream.
Critics think that allowing crypto exemptions would incentivize companies to manipulate asset classifications. Over time, the lines between crypto and traditional assets would blur, complicating enforcement for regulators like the IRS.
Tracking and taxing income would become exponentially harder, and the tax base would shrink as more wealth escapes into crypto loopholes. This creates a new problem: the cost of policing these schemes. The IRS would need significant resources to audit crypto transactions effectively.
Given its existing struggles with staffing and funding, critics wonder if the agency could handle the added burden. The exemption might save crypto investors money, but at what cost to the rest of the economy?
Federal revenue and the budget deficit
America’s budget deficit hit $1.8 trillion in 2024. Capital gains taxes are a critical part of this equation, contributing billions annually. Exempting crypto could blow a hole in federal revenue streams at a time when deficits are already unsustainable.
Supporters of Trump’s plan argue that the economic growth spurred by crypto would offset these losses. But skeptics aren’t convinced. They point out that crypto, while growing fast, remains a fraction of the overall economy.
Even with explosive growth, it’s unlikely to replace the revenue lost from eliminating capital gains taxes. To make up the shortfall, the government would need to raise taxes elsewhere or cut spending on public services. Either option is politically fraught and could create new economic challenges.
The crypto industry doesn’t need tax breaks to thrive—it needs regulatory clarity and consistency. A tax exemption might provide a temporary boost, but it creates long-term uncertainty. Future administrations could always just reverse the policy, throwing the industry into chaos.
Trump’s “America first” approach with crypto could backfire on the global stage. Crypto is inherently international, relying on borderless networks and decentralized systems. Policies that prioritize one country’s assets over others risk fragmenting the ecosystem.
From Zero to Web3 Pro: Your 90-Day Career Launch Plan
