Beijing Court Makes Landmark Decision Granting Copyright to AI-Generated Image

Beijing Court Makes Landmark Decision Granting Copyright to AI-Generated Image

Most read

Loading Most Ready posts..


  • Beijing Court grants copyright to AI-generated image, ruling in favour of the producer in a lawsuit against a blogger for unauthorized usage.
  • Judge identifies the human creator as the author, highlighting their intellectual contributions and aesthetic choices in generating the image.
  • This landmark decision sets a potential precedent for future disputes involving AI-generated content and copyright, signalling evolving legal recognition in the digital age.

In a groundbreaking ruling, the court in Beijing, China, granted copyright to an image generated by artificial intelligence (AI) after the producer took legal action against a blogger for unauthorized usage. 

Court Awards Copyright Status to AI-generated Image

The plaintiff, who identified himself as Mr. Li, created the image using Stable Diffusion, an AI image generator. Subsequently, Ms. Liu, a blogger, used the image without authorization, including removing all watermarks and identifications.

Mr. Li initiated a copyright violation lawsuit against Ms. Liu at the Beijing Internet Court, resulting in an order for Ms. Liu to pay damages of $70 (CN¥500) and costs of $7 (CN¥50). The central question before the court was whether copyright could be attributed to an AI-generated image. Judge Zhu Ge ruled in favor, asserting that the image met the criteria because it embodied Mr. Li’s intellectual contributions and aesthetic choices.

The judge explicitly identified Mr. Li as the author, not the AI system Stability AI that produced Stable Diffusion. This determination was based on Mr. Li’s extensive involvement in character presentation, including intellectual investments in prompt word selection, arrangement of prompt words, parameter settings, and image selection based on expectations.

According to the court’s ruling, “The picture involved reflects the plaintiff’s intellectual investment, so the picture involved meets the requirements of ‘intellectual achievement.'”

Legal Implications for AI-Generated Content

It’s worth noting that the Beijing Internet Court handles unique cases related to the Internet, even though it is not China’s highest intellectual property (IP) court. China does have a specialized IP court, and legal experts speculate that this decision may not necessarily set a precedent and could be subject to review by superior courts.

Andres Guadamuz of TechnoLlama acknowledged the court’s decision but pointed out that it might potentially be reversed or disregarded by other courts. Nevertheless, this ruling is significant, particularly in the context of generative AI. Judge Zhu Ge stated that this verdict would provide guidance for future disputes involving AI-generated content.

This case highlights the legal complexities arising from AI-created content and copyright issues. Legal systems are evolving to address the intricacies of copyright in the digital age as AI continues to advance. The Beijing court’s ruling marks a significant departure from a previous standpoint that did not recognize the creative contributions of humans using AI tools and raises important questions about the potential for copyrights in AI-produced creations.

Disclaimer. The information provided is not trading advice. Cryptopolitan.com holds no liability for any investments made based on the information provided on this page. We strongly recommend independent research and/or consultation with a qualified professional before making any investment decisions.

Share link:

Ibiam Wayas

Ibiam is an optimistic crypto journalist. Five years from now, he sees himself establishing a unique crypto media outlet that will breach the gap between the crypto world and the general public. He loves to associate with like-minded individuals and collaborate with them on similar projects. He spends much of his time honing his writing and critical thinking skills.

Stay on top of crypto news, get daily updates in your inbox

Related News

Subscribe to CryptoPolitan